Pregnancy & Baby Index: Parenting Toddlers: Potty Training: Hello cloth, good-bye disposables
Hello cloth, good-bye disposables
Amy Rawson
In the past, using cloth diapers has provoked visions of horrid odors, heavy pails of water and hours of extra work for mom. Many mothers never even give it a second thought and cases of disposables are a welcome sight at a baby shower. In reality, nothing could be further from the truth. Cloth diapers are just as easy to use, more economical and are healthier for your baby's skin.
Cloth diaper pluses
Cloth is breathable and keeps bottoms cooler-less irritation to skin
More frequent changes mean healthier skin. The leading cause of diaper rash is due to prolonged exposure to urine or feces.
No chemicals and/or gel getting on baby's skin
Cloth diapering mothers swear earlier potty training --
at least earlier recognition of body functions. For a child to want to
stay dry, he or she has to not want to feel wet. A disposable makes
that hard to distinguish because of the capacity for absorbing such
large amounts of urine.
Styles of diapers
Flat. A large square diaper that is folded and generally pinned
or clipped using a diaper clip. A cover of your choice is needed. These
are what most people think of when using cloth.
Prefold. A rectangular diaper, usually with a thick layer in the
center third. To use, simply fold into itself so you have a multi
layered rectangle and lay in a cover, then lay baby on it all and
fasten cover.
Hourglass or fitted. Contoured to give a slimmer fit, usually
with extra absorbent layer sewn in. elastic leg opening, some close
with velcro or snaps and others use simple pins or clips. You can use a
separate doubler for extra nighttime absorbency if you find you need
to. These need a cover.
AIO. All In One's are the fanciest of all cloth. Just as
convenient and easy to use as a disposable. Like the hourglass or
fitted style, they also have a waterproof layer in their construction.
Great for converting the unsure family member to cloth and if using the
AIO, you may be able to use them for daycare. The only downside is that
unless you sew them yourself they are a bit more expensive and take
extra time to dry. It is
worth having a few for times when an extra hour or two is needed
between changes.
Covers
Unless you use the AIO style diaper, you will need a cover for your
diapers. Many moms have their babies go without a cover at home and
this allows for more breathability, but going out requires a waterproof
layer.
Covers can be as simple as buying a pack of plastic pants at
your local store. I recommend looking for the nylon style for
durability and be sure to check the leg openings for soft elastic. Some
plastic pants can have scratchy gathers at the opening which makes
sore, irritated legs.
Covers are also available in a contour shape that you snap or velcro
over the diaper underneath. These come in treated cotton or polyester,
felted wool or plastic with a cloth layer on the outside for looks. For
a fancier style, covers are available in fleece, hemp or wool. These
styles can be a bit more expensive but can be used for more than one
diaper change. Unless soiled, there is no need to wash more than one
time every week or two.
A good technique is to have three of these covers, one on the baby, one
ready to go and one air drying. (I have three wool soakers that are
pull ons. They are lanolized by me and washed in the bathroom sink
every couple of weeks.)
Cost
There is a huge difference between the cost of cloth versus
disposables. "Disposable diapers cost between $1500 and $2100 over the
course of the three years it takes the average child to be toilet
trained," said Diane
Weathers of Consumer Reports.
A complete setup of adjustable cloth diapers with waterproof
covers can be purchased for less than $500.00. (I purchased 24 diapers,
12 doublers for $214 -- which included shipping -- then purchased three
wool soakers for
$3.50 each, along with five nylon-coated pull on covers that I bought
secondhand for .25 each, this is my entire diapering supply.) If you
purchase used diapers at thrift stores offline and auctions/swapboards
online, you can save even more. And if you sew, you can design the
exact style and thickness you desire for very little effort.
Unlike the constant purchasing of disposables, you can buy one
cloth setup, which can then be used throughout baby- and toddlerhood!
With proper care the same diapers can be used for the next child.
A few words on absorbency comparisons
Even though most disposable users just wrap and toss used diapers,
the package of disposables states "TO DISPOSE: PLEASE DO NOT LITTER.
Dump loose soil into toilet. Wrap or fold up diaper and discard in
waste receptacle. DO NOT FLUSH DIAPER." (Taken directly from a package
of disposable diapers.)
The
diaper companies stress that their diapers are more biodegradable than
ever, but they don't mention that the biodegradability only applies if
the diaper is folded inside out and exposed to air and sunlight. This
is just not the case in a landfill.
The idea that a disposable is more absorbent is a moot point.
On the packaging, it says that a baby should be changed when wet or
soiled. The fact that the diaper can hold large amounts of is
irrelevant. To leave a child in a disposable until maximum capacity is
reached is unthinkable, so that argument isn't valid. You do change a
cloth-diapered baby more often but you should be changing a disposable-diapered baby just as often.
With cloth, the simplest solution would be to purchase flushable liners
(Flushabyes and Kushies Disposable Liners) and at changing time, lift
off soiled liner and flush contents. You then have a soil free
(although wet) diaper to put into the pail. Which leads me to the next
step...